Photo

Rating 1 star



Summary

Not Recommended. Outdated people-carrier lags behind more modern rivals. It has room for seven, but the third-row seats are a struggle to remove.

Review

Once one of the best people-carriers, the Sharan now feels very dated by the standards set by more modern rivals. Not only does it look old, but the interior feels downmarket and the optional seven-seat layout isn't particularly easy to use.

Space is good for five occupants sitting in the front and middle row, but the third row seats are cramped for anybody except small children and they are awkward to fold or remove. Running as a five-seater, bootspace is good, but with all seven seats in use luggage space is very limited.

The Sharan drives with an unpretentious competence. Handling is safe and roadholding is assured up to the relatively modest limits of the chassis. Motorway cruising refinement is relatively poor, though, with lots of wind and road noise getting into the cabin at speed.

A simplified range of engines includes just one petrol powerplant, a desperately underpowered 2.0 litre unit. The two diesel motors are far better, although both the 1.9 and 2.0 litre TDIs are loud by modern standards.

Breakdown

Styling 1 star

The Sharan's fundamental design dates back to 1995 - and it shows. The styling was never very imaginative, but it looks seriously dated now.

Handling 1 star

Safe and predictable, although the Sharan isn't the sort of car to raise the pulse on a twisty road.

Comfort 1 star

Spacious as a five-seater, but cramped for seven. Ride quality is good, but road and wind noise are too high at motorway cruising speeds.

Quality & reliability 1 star

Solidly constructed but completely lacking in any feeling of specialness. Cabin materials are cheap by modern standards.

Performance 1 star

The base 2.0 litre petrol engine is well worth avoiding - it really struggles to motivate the Sharan's bulk. 1.9 litre TDI diesel is the most sensible powerplant in the range. The 2.0 litre TDI is loud, but it does give the Sharan a decent turn of speed.

Roominess 1 star

It was one of the first seven-seat people-carriers, but the Sharan's third row seats are cramped and awkward to use. The game has moved on.

Running costs 1 star

Residual values have started to slip - the Sharan only makes financial sense with a generous discount. Servicing and insurance costs are reasonable and the diesels turn in decent fuel economy.

Value for money 1 star

The Sharan's official list price looks very steep compared to more modern seven-seat rivals. Big discounts are available as VW dealers struggle to move the metal.

Stereo / Sat nav 1 star

The old-fashioned audio system gives average sound. Satnav is only available on the very top of the range - it's an outdated system and not really worth specifying.

Comments

From:  
Email:     
Comment:   
Send article to a friend
Your name:
Friend's name:
Friend's email:
Search reviews
 
reviews index
AddThis Social Bookmark Button