Photo

Rating 1 star



Summary

Average. Volkswagen's strangest car - the Phaeton is an amazingly well-engineered luxury saloon, but it has struggled without the premium badge that buyers in this segment expect, and running costs are horrendous.

Review

There's no doubting that the Phaeton is an astonishing car, the result of Volkswagen's decision to attempt to create a rival to the BMW 7-Series, Mercedes S-Class and even the Audi A8, which shares many of its mechanical components with the Phaeton. Unfortunately for Volkswagen, the combination of high prices and very steep depreciation has ensured that the Phaeton remains a very rare sight.

Exterior styling is understated to the point of almost being dull - it looks like an XXL version of the far-cheaper Passat. But the opulent interior redresses the balance with some very snazzy details, although the over-complicated dashboard lacks the clarity of rivals. There's plenty of space for four full sized adults, and Volkswagen claims that the advanced four-zone climate control is capable of keeping the cabin cool even when driving at full speed across a hot desert.

Dynamically, the Phaeton feels more like a limousine than a sports saloon, wafting away long journeys and cruising amazingly quietly on motorways. On narrower roads it feels big and unwieldy and its sheer size makes it difficult to park in town.

The 4.2 litre V8 is rapid and the 6.0 litre W12, which uses a version of the same engine fitted to the Audi A8 and Bentley Continental, is ridiculously fast. The only sensible powertrain choice in the range is the 3.0 litre TDI diesel, which combines decent urge with reasonable fuel economy.

Specification levels are high, including standard automatic transmission and "4Motion" four-wheel drive, but all Phaetons suffer from high running costs and punishing depreciation.

Breakdown

Styling 1 star

Bland exterior styling makes the Phaeton the least visually arresting full-sized executive saloon. Looks like a big Passat.

Handling 1 star

Very stable at motorway cruising speeds but it feels too big and wide for comfortable progress along narrower roads.

Comfort 1 star

The ultra-comfortable cabin is a great place to spend time, in either the front or rear seats. High-speed cruising is amazingly quiet.

Quality & reliability 1 star

Very well put together inside and out, although some of the cabin materials feel a bit chintzy and lack the class of more understated rivals.

Performance 1 star

The hopelessly under-powered 3.2 litre petrol V6 has now been dropped, thankfully. The petrol V8 and W12 engines offer good performance, although they consume fuel faster than oilwell fires. The 3.0 litre TDI is the only sensible engine in the range - it's a shame VW doesn't offer Brits the 5.0 litr

Roominess 1 star

Both standard and long-wheelbase versions are spacious for four full-sized occupants with plenty of leg-room and head-room all-round. The boot is impressively large, although practicality is limited by the inability to fold the rear seats.

Running costs 1 star

Horrendous residual values really undermine the Phaeton's appeal - the W12 loses nearly three quarters of its value in just three years. Servicing and insurance are both expensive and the petrol versions are very thirsty.

Value for money 1 star

Volkswagen just can't match the brand appeal of established executive players so the Phaeton's steep asking price makes it look like poor value, despite good standard equipment - including satnav.

Stereo / Sat nav 1 star

The audio system gives brilliant sound quality throughout the cabin. Satnav works well, but the screen is too bright and distracting.

Comments

From:  
Email:     
Comment:   
Send article to a friend
Your name:
Friend's name:
Friend's email:
Search reviews
 
reviews index
AddThis Social Bookmark Button