Netcars.co.uk - The search starts here
Photo

Rating 1 star



Summary

Average. Full marks to Toyota for putting this hybrid into production, but sadly the reality can't live up to the hype.

Review

If you believe some people then the Toyota Prius, and cars like it, represents the future of personal transportation. It uses a hybrid drivetrain - a petrol engine working in conjunction with electric motors - to "regenerate" some of the energy that ordinary cars lose through braking and cruising, allowing it to turn in turn in impressive fuel economy figures without the need to resort to a dirty diesel engine.

That's the theory, anyway. The reality on British roads is slightly different, where even the most well-driven Prius will have serious difficulty in getting close to its 65.7 mpg combined fuel economy figure. In truth it's been designed for traffic clogged Californian freeways rather than Britain's faster-flowing motorways, and for most journeys the fuel economy is little better than that of a conventional petrol-powered hatchback - and considerably worse than a similarly sized diesel.

Fortunately, for those looking to pin their green credentials to their sleeve, the Prius requires users to make a minimal number of sacrifices when it comes to being, well, pious. From the user's point of view, pretty much everything about the car is conventional, from the unexciting styling to the spacious cabin and unintimidating driving experience. It can feel a little bit odd when the car pulls away from a standstill under exclusively electric power, but once the engine fires up (driving through a clever constantly variable transmission) it feels like you're in charge of a conventional automatic.

Performance is impressively keen, at low speeds at least, with the electric motors giving a welcome slug of power when called upon to do so. The flip-side is poor motorway performance, with the Prius's comfortable cruising speed being a fair bit less than that you'll typically find on a British motorway. The ride feels rough and lots of wind and road noise get into the cabin. On twisty roads it acquits itself honourably, lacking much in the way of grip but staying safe and predictable as the limits approach.

Breakdown

Styling 1 star

Bland looks feel like they were chosen so as not to offend the all-important American market. The front end has a bit of character, but it gets more boring the further you move round.

Handling 1 star

Limits are low, but the Prius is safe and predictable as they approach.

Comfort 1 star

The ride feels a bit over-firm when traversing rougher tarmac and a fair amount of road and wind noise gets into the cabin.

Quality & reliability 1 star

The cabin doesn't feel that special, but there's no doubting the quality of the engineering beneath the Prius's surface.

Performance 1 star

Impressively rapid at lower speeds, and the electric motors give a welcome extra slug of urge for overtaking, but it feels out of its depth when it comes to motorway cruising.

Roominess 1 star

Considering the need to package the electric motors and batteries into the body, Toyota has done an impressive job in creating a spacious cabin and a generously sized boot.

Running costs 1 star

Despite its environmental credentials, the Prius isn't as cost effective as you might think. Poor residual values reflect the suspicion of expensive work down the line when it comes to battery replacement, and in our experience it's almost impossible to get within 10 mpg of the claimed fuel economy

Value for money 1 star

Toyota is almost certainly losing money on each Prius sold, such is the value of the engineering built into it. But compared to conventional turbo-diesel family hatchbacks it looks expensive and slightly under-equipped.

Stereo / Sat nav 1 star

The standard audio system works well and the satnav (standard on the range-topping T-Spirit) is easy to use.

Comments

From:  
Email:     
Comment:   
Send article to a friend
Your name:
Friend's name:
Friend's email:
Search reviews
 
reviews index
AddThis Social Bookmark Button