Netcars.co.uk - The search starts here

Mercedes A Class

Photo

Rating 1 star



Summary

Recommended. Clever supermini that offers excellent practicality in addition to a premium badge - it's just not that great to drive.

Review

The A Class remains a car pretty much without rivals, especially now that Audi has killed off the unsuccessful A2. The second-generation A Class carries on where the original left off - it's a practical, spacious and well-built supermini with the additional attraction of a three-pointed star on the bonnet.

The distinctive design is pleasing enough, but it's when you get inside that the A Class starts to become really clever, with a very spacious cabin considering its compact external dimensions. There's plenty of room for four adults (although rear seat access is a bit awkward in the three-door) and the baby Merc also boasts one of the biggest boots in the segment.

The good news is that this A Class is far more comfortable than its bouncy, hard-riding predecessor. The suspension now has a decent amount of compliance, while motorway speed cruising is impressively relaxed for something so small.

The downside is an indifferent dynamic performance on anything other than arrow-straight roads. The A Class's steering suffers from very artificial-feeling weighting, the chassis quickly runs out of front-end grip and the electronic stability system cuts in far too early if you try and turn up the pace.

At least buyers have a comprehensive range of engines to choose between with four petrols and three diesels on offer. However, steep pricing means the A Class offers progressively worse value as you move up the range, so we'd recommend the respectably rapid entry level "150" petrol engine as the optimal powerplant.

Breakdown

Styling 1 star

Handsome, distinctive and completely unique - the A Class is a perfect choice for those who want to stand out from the herd.

Handling 1 star

Indifferent handling means the A Class can't match the dynamic appeal of most of its rivals. Good in straight lines and at higher speeds, but not much cop in corners.

Comfort 1 star

The cabin is spacious, well finished and good to spend time in, and although ride quality is still a bit hard-edged, this A Class is vastly better than its bouncy predecessor.

Quality & reliability 1 star

Generally very well assembled, although a couple of areas of the cabin still feel cheap - especially considering the pricetags of more expensive versions.

Performance 1 star

All engines except the basic A160 CDI diesel offer decent amounts of urge, with the range-topping A200 Turbo being downright speedy.

Roominess 1 star

The A Class crams plenty of practicality into its compact dimensions with a spacious, well-finished cabin and a decently sized boot.

Running costs 1 star

The A Class crams plenty of practicality into its compact dimensions with a spacious, well-finished cabin and a decently sized boot.

Value for money 1 star

Stingy base spec means having to pay extra for air conditioning on the entry level versions, while the A Class is massively expensive at the top of the range - you really are being made to fork out for the Mercedes badge.

Stereo / Sat nav 1 star

The standard audio system is decent and the optional upgraded system is very good. Basic satnav isn't great, but the more advanced full-colour system is excellent

Comments

From: James WhiteDate: 01/06/2007 15:20:31
Comment:  Good car - dream to drive and extremely reliable. Good value for money.
From:  
Email:     
Comment:   
Send article to a friend
Your name:
Friend's name:
Friend's email:
Search reviews
 
reviews index
AddThis Social Bookmark Button