Netcars.co.uk - The search starts here
Photo

Rating 1 star



Summary

Not recommended. A good Idea? Hardly. This is another cross between a supermini and an MPV, but it's too boring and too expensive to make any real sense.

Review

Manufacturers love to talk about "crossover" thinking - building cars that are meant to combine the virtues of two different market segments. And as such, Fiat reckons we should look on the Idea as being a cross between a small people-carrier and a supermini.

It's a good idea, but one that the Idea really doesn't manage to capitalise on very well. Indeed, since the launch of the equally spacious Grande Punto, it's become very hard to make any real case for this decidedly inferior offering.

The bland design looks like it belongs in the late 1990s rather than the early 21st century - the Idea looks like a slightly rounded off box from the outside. In the cabin things are no better, with cheap plastics everywhere and very dated-looking design. At least there's plenty of space for front and rear seat passengers, although the boot is barely bigger than that of the Grande Punto.

On the road the Idea proves itself to be a very dull little appliance. Handling is safe enough, but grip levels are low and a rubbery gearshift and feel-free steering effectively remove any feelings of driver involvement. On the plus side, at least it rides reasonably well.

Engine choice is limited to a breathless-feeling 1.4 litre petrol engine or an underpowered 1.3 litre "MultiJet" turbo diesel. Both are priced too close to proper mid-sized people-carriers to make much sense as new purchases.

Breakdown

Styling 1 star

Dull and boring - the Idea is completely lacking in the sort of design magic that gives the Panda and Grande Punto their appeal.

Handling 1 star

Inert and lifeless on the road, with a rubbery gearshift and vague steering. Not the sort of car you'll ever want to drive for anything more than A-to-B.

Comfort 1 star

The driving position is reasonable for a car in this segment and ride quality is decent enough over rougher road surfaces.

Quality & reliability 1 star

Compared to Fiat's more modern products, the Idea feels like a really backward step. Cheap-feeling cabin is very disappointing considering the five-figure pricetags.

Performance 1 star

1.4 litre petrol is adequately rapid, although it feels a bit strained at higher revs. MultiJet diesel is smooth and economical but really lacks urge.

Roominess 1 star

There's plenty of room in the big cabin for four occupants, although there's barely more space than the cheaper Grande Punto.

Running costs 1 star

Decent fuel economy and cheap servicing helps the Idea keep running costs competitive, although petrol versions suffer from steep depreciation.

Value for money 1 star

Expensive compared to direct rivals and with poor standard kit, the base Idea doesn't even get air conditioning.

Stereo / Sat nav 1 star

The audio system gives reasonable performance, but satnav isn't even available as an option.

Comments

From:  
Email:     
Comment:   
Send article to a friend
Your name:
Friend's name:
Friend's email:
Search reviews
 
reviews index
AddThis Social Bookmark Button