Netcars.co.uk - The search starts here
Photo

Rating 1 star



Summary

Average. Sensible and practical transport, but without the quality or dynamics to be anything more than a segment also-ran.

Review

Big and unarguably useful, the Croma is another of the growing number of attempts to reinvent the family car. Fiat has incorporated lots of cues from MPVs into it, including tall construction and a spacious cabin, but the rest of the driving and ownership experience is profoundly average.

Despite slightly awkward visual proportions, the Croma is a reasonable enough looking car from the outside. Once inside the cabin is spacious and solidly constructed, but lots of the materials feel very cheap when compared to rivals. Rear seat space is decent, but the boot isn't as big as you'd expect - unable to match the VW Passat estate on overall volume.

On the road, the Croma drives very well - providing you're not anticipating white-knuckle driving dynamics. Soft suspension helps to smooth out bumps, while high-speed refinement is very good. On twisty roads the chassis can't evince much interest for faster progress, though, with big lean angles and poor grip from the front end.

It's hard to make too much of a case for the petrol engines, although the smooth-spinning 2.2 litre unit goes very nicely indeed. But the diesels are the better powerplants by far, especially the entry level 120 bhp 1.9 litre JTD engine. The more potent 150 bhp version gives more urge and pretty much matches the lesser motor's fuel economy, but its noisier and with a peakier power delivery. The range-topping 2.4 litre JTD is thirsty and barely more rapid than the 1.9.

Breakdown

Styling 1 star

Boring but practical - the Croma looks like it emerged fully formed from a jelly mould.

Handling 1 star

Safe and predictable, but not the sort of car you're ever going to choose to chuck around for fun.

Comfort 1 star

Soothing ride, good driving position and impressive motorway refinement make the Croma an easy car to spend time with.

Quality & reliability 1 star

It feels tough enough, but interior trim quality is nothing like that of classier rivals.

Performance 1 star

The petrol engines are pretty much pointless - entry-level 120 bhp diesel motor is by far the sweetest model in the range.

Roominess 1 star

As big and practical as you would expect from something that looks like this.

Running costs 1 star

Fuel, insurance and servicing costs are all competitive - but the Croma's disastrous residuals mean it looks expensive on a cost-per-mile basis.

Value for money 1 star

Well priced against the competition considering the amount of standard equipment on offer - until you remember the punishing depreciation.

Stereo / Sat nav 1 star

Audio system lacks features but offers decent quality. Satnav is reasonably priced compared to rivals, but the system is slow to react.

Comments

From: johnlDate: 29/01/2007 11:32:03
Comment:  if it had a bmw badge it would of got five stars.
From: Denis PlaterDate: 29/01/2007 08:47:35
Comment:  I have owned a Fiat Croma 150 Multijet Diesel Eleganza since July 2006. As a self employed corporate Management Training Consultant my monthly mileage tops 2500 (use cars up pretty quickly). The car is comfortable works well usually only me in it. Its particularly economical 45 + mpg which clearly suits my purpose. I would probably have another except I have'nt seen any others on the road (bit worrying for trade-in - probably have to buy another Fiat to satisfy the whims of the motor trade) Chea
From: Philip DjaferisDate: 29/01/2007 05:26:08
Comment:  if you're talking about used cars, deprecitaion ought to be a plus, as you're buying a bargain instrad of inflated prices for other cars...comparing the Croma to the Passat estate which costs a lot more is not fair; compare it to a Vecrea or Mondea saloon and then the equation is different. The Croma was never meant to be compared to large estates; you the press are misunderstanding it and giving poor ratings on 'quality and reliability' and on 'value for money' when the Fiat is actually pret
From:  
Email:     
Comment:   
Send article to a friend
Your name:
Friend's name:
Friend's email:
Search reviews
 
reviews index
AddThis Social Bookmark Button